1.75 Acre Lots in Margarita Sixaola sold Fraudulently on the Internet

This page has been created and updated due to the continuous flow of clients that have contacted or visited our offices looking for land they have purchased on the Internet over the past few years. The number of victims appears to be increasing and we feel it is time to do whatever possible to stop this real estate scam. Countless people have fallen victim to the scam outlined below...and no one has ever been able to stop the perpetuator - YET! By putting this information together, we hope to accomplish several things:

1. Bring awareness to local community and the internet public of the existence of this scam. Most potential buyers of these properties would most likely do a search for information on the seller and properties. We hope they will come across this information prior to sending their money to the seller.

2. Provide a wealth of information available to victims, law enforcement personnel and agencies. The perpetuator has created a web of deceitful information that many victims, topographers, attorneys and law enforcement officials have had a hard time pinpointing. The perpetuator is a professional and has created a web of misinformation to trick his victims. We hope this presentation speaks for itself and will provide enough information to cease this activity.

3. Inform victims of the scam and discourage them from attempting to resell the same scam (unknowingly) to other potential buyers - as is actively happening today. Many victims have been successful in getting refunded when they put sufficient pressure on the seller.

4. Bring awareness to real buyers: DO NOT EVER purchase real estate sight unseen!!!

5. Discourage the perpetuator to stop these activities by exposing his tactics and hopefully sending him where he belongs!

As a professional and licensed realtor in Costa Rica, I would like make a few statements about purchasing real estate in Costa Rica: Despite this bold scam that has been going on for many years and has yet to be stopped, this is an exception and a rare one. It is otherwise not dangerous or risky to purchase real estate in Costa Rica - IF - you follow the same laws and principles you would in your own country. First and foremost, NEVER purchase something you have not seen! To my knowledge, none of the people who have purchased these lots had visited the area or seen the properties prior to purchasing them. Second, always work with a recommended and licensed realtor - there is a reason why they are licensed and have established a reputation. And third, the golden rule: If it is too good to be true...then it IS too good to be true! The offered prices (usually under US$10,000) are far cheaper then anything else you could find around here and are certainly attractive and easy to purchase with a credit card.

The Scam:

The perpetuator, the seller, Mr Michael Leu, and perhaps his surrogates promotes and sells lots located just outside the Puerto Viejo area near Margarita - Sixaola. Weunderstand that he also runs a similar operation on the other coast near Jaco. The lots are mostly promoted as 1.75 acre ocean view lots. He usually sells them individually, sometimes 2 or 3 at a time and at other times has sold the ENTIRE block of over 100 lots to individual "investors"!

The lots may have been sold via the mail system prior to the existence of the Internet. In recent years, they have been sold on EBAY, his own web site CRLANDINVEST.COM (which seems to have been taken down as of 2010_07), numerous auction sites, and many other real estate by owner web sites. Our agency has received a number of requests from unknown victims to "resell" their properties - only to be informed of this scam.

The lots are promoted as having ocean view. No properties in that area have ocean view.

The lots are promoted as ready to build with "nearby" electricity, roads and septic sewer systems in place. There is no electricity, there are no roads, there is no subdivision, there are no septic sewage systems, the land is raw jungle and sometimes very steep.

We checked with the local municipality and they have no knowledge of such a development. We checked with all the neighbors - including those on the supposed land survey - and none have ever heard of such a development - or such a neighbor!

Despite many victims that fly down to locate their investment once they have made the final payment - none have ever found the lots. Topographers have been hired - neighbors have been harassed - some even sued - and yet no buyer has ever ended up with what they purchased. We have asked Mr Michael Leu to come down and show us the lots, or send someone down that knows them - but we have been ignored. He has never done so - not for us and not for any of his buyers and he has blocked the emails addresses from angry folks trying to contacting him.

The "title" that the seller awards his buyers is a Quit Claim Deed in the US. Absolutely no legal Costa Rican paperwork, contract or sales document is provided. Buyers arrive in Costa Rica with apparent "proof" of their purchase with paperwork that is meaningless in this country. He has been presenting as proof that his title exists –a Stewart Title Guarantee.  Stewart Title has been contacted and they have no such record of Mr Leu’s Title Guarantee.

The seller does provide a reference to a large titled property in the name of his corporation and a land survey, but this is most likely a fraud and it does not reflect the property that has been purchased. We have recently hired a licensed professional topographer to study the subject “planos” or land surveys.  The report clearly demonstrates serious inconsistencies with the claimed location of the properties versus their original location – and further demonstrates that the seller’s “registered land” invalidates or sits on top of  at least seven other legitimate land owners.

Since the transaction amounts are usually under US$10,000, it is often not worthy of the victim to pursue the claim legally as it can be expensive and tiresome. The seller is playing between 2 legal systems and somehow falling between the cracks of both - somehow evading law enforcement to stop his deceitful activities.

We have tried to contact Mr Leu about his activities. He did reply - only to say that he was under investigation and he could not discuss anything - prior to blocking my email address from contacting him again. Since then we have been unsuccessful in contacting him. However, we have received many threatening emails and telephone calls - informing us that we will be sued for "defaming" him. At first we took him seriously, but soon realized this is just a planned tactic of his to try to scare off his adversaries. He has recently been sending to all his “clients” that question his motives – a document supposedly saying that I – am the person defaming him and spreading false information – and occupying his land.  Upon review of that “lawsuit” and accusation, neither my name nor any valid finca numbers are presented.  At first we took him seriously, but soon realized this is just a planned tactic of his to try to scare off his adversaries.

An example: Where is lot 25?
The maps below show the lots that are being sold during the period July 2009 on the internet. Notice that the SAME map is being used at least 5 different times to resell the same lots - just changing the orientation of the map and the lots numbers. Keep in mind that these same lots have been sold and sold over at least the past 20 years! We took Lot 25 just as a random example and highlighted it in blue on the first map. ON the next 4 maps, you will notice that lot 25 gets moved to another location and on the next 3 maps, it is renumbered to a different series of lots. All of these maps are actively being marketing simultaneously on the Internet as of July 2009. There is only one land survey (it is registered but we believe it is fraudulent), yet there are five different subdivisions!

This is the map used in this particular online sale. Lot 25 is in BLUE on the right side.

Notice how that same "physical" Location gets move, changed and renumbered...

Lots 001 through 120

Notice the map has flipped
and inverted and
the SAME property numbers
appear in different locations!
Lots 121 through 230

What was lot 25 has now become 125.
Lots 231 through 340

Map has been flipped again
and a new series of lot
numbers assigned
Lots 341 through 449

Map has been inverted and
yet another set of lot
numbers assigned
Lots 559 through 667

And one more time
The same lot 25 is now Lot 5
...or did it move to the other side?
  Now Lot 25 is Lot 255 Now Lot 25 is Lot 347 ...and now it becomes 565

 

 

       
 
How the lots are promoted
Below are a number of examples taken from the Internet recently...one can easily see a pattern of deception. Note that in some cases, the seller is either a surrogate of Mr Leu - or a victim that is either knowingly helping or unknowingly copying Mr Leu in an attempt to make a quick profit. We have printed PDF snapshots of the sites - in case they are taken down off the Internet or the auction expires.

 

Lot 025 on EscapeArtist.com
Lot 033 on CottageLink.com
Lot 038 on LandsalesListing.com
Lot 075 on Bid4Assets.com
Lot 084 on Bid4Assets.com
Lot 086 on Bid4Assets.com
Lot 087 on IOffer.com
Lot 092 on EZBids.com
Lot 106 on IOffer.com
Lots 260-262 on EscapeArtist.com
Lot 359 onLiveAuctioneers.com
Lot 476 on Bid4Assets.com
Lot 595 onEZBids.com
Lots 10-11 on IOffer.com
Lot 582 on Kijiji.com
Lot 00x on other web site

Note: The web site has removed
all listings by the seller
as of 27 July, 2009
upon notification
Lot 407 on EBAY.com

Lot 596 on EscapeArtist.com
Lot 596 on EBAY.com
Lot 429 on EBAY.com
       
       
       
Legal (???)Archives
Purchase of Property in 2002


  • Signed on 4 October 2002 in San Diego California USA
  • Seller: Herbert Clark Savage as representative of H & M S.A.
  • Buyer : Harold Henry Ruppert as representative of International Investments in Land ML & HR, S.A.
  • Notary: Cristina Anahi Naranjo Galloni
  • Topographer: Jose A Reyes Cordero N. 11329

States that the seller is owner of a property with title number 7_0013438_000 and an land size of 3,064,896.76 M2

States that the lands size should be magically changed to 974,472.00 M2 as represented by the new plot map L-0814331-2002

States that the neighbors are a, b, c & d and to be changed to w, x, y & z

Also states that the location and usage description should be rectified.

In other words....this document appears to change the land size, geographical location, neighbors and characteristics of the property - amongst many other things. From a realtor's perspective: very suspect!!!

Topographical Analysis
November 2009: We have hired the services of a professional and liscensed topographer from TOPOCAT S.A. They have presented to us 3 graphical displays of the property supposedly being sold:

Original Land Survey
Number L-009398-1971
Size: 3,064,896.76 M2

Newest Land Survey
Number L-0814331-2002
Size: 974,472.00 M2

This is what the Purchase of Property document above says has happened and wants us to believe. This is the REAL situation....both properties have nothing to do with each other - further suggesting that the Purchase of Property document above is falsefied and fraudulent. Title based on false and inaccurate information

 

---------------------->

The collage to the right shows all the plot maps (land surverys) registered for this region. Note that the Property supposedly owned by Mr Michael Leu is buried (almost hidden) by other REAL properties with REAL owners...

What is more logical: many people that physically live on their lands and pay their municipal taxes or one crook in his living room in Ohio claiming that everyone else is squatting on his land - and does NOT pay his municipal taxes?

------------------------>

       
Corporate Ownership
Certificate
Other Properties Owned
by the Seller
  Written report from Topographer detailing his findings
 
Seller's Title
Quit Claim Deed Lot 88
 
Michael Leu's Website
<---This is the ONLY proof of your ownership of the property ...which means absolutely nothing in Costa Rica...it is juts a piece of paper
       
       
What can you do?
       
<----- On August 29th 2008, AM Costa Rica www.amcostarica.com ran a story on this situation. Since then, it appears that Mr Leu is longer selling on EBAY - or at least a lot less ....could it have helped? Several other blogs and sites picked up the story and reran it.

We encourage AM Costa Rica and other news outlets to cover this story again...get it out into the public before their are many more victims.
<------Let the public know on Message Boards and other forums

This one from IRIPOFF.com is fairly active

WeLoveCostaRica.com Forum 1
WeLoveCostaRica.com Forum 2

American-European.net Forum 1
...more recent press coverage
Article on PuertoViejoSatellite.com Artcile on WeLoveCostaRica.com    
   

Are you a victim?
Or an attorney, a topographer or law enforcement person that can help?

We have a list of victims, attorneys, media and other professionals with knowledge of this situation that have agreed to have their names and contact information shared with others like you in order to pool all information, proof, tactics, source, successful results, etc so that as a group we can put a stop to this fraud.


File a complaint with the Ohio Attorney General

Visit the FBI Internet Fraud Page

File a complaint with the Better Business Bureau

File a complaint with the Internet Crime Complaint  Center

File a complaint with the National Fraud Information Center

Contact law enforcement officials at the local and state level your local and state police departments

Find your nearest FBI office

Cleveland Ohio FBI Office:
FBI Cleveland
Federal Office Building
1501 Lakeside Avenue
Cleveland, Ohio 44114
(216) 522-1400
cleveland.fbi.gov

Perpetrator's Address
:
7705 St. James Dr.
Mentor, OH 44060



For more information or to report a case, please contact us:

margarita@caribesur-realestate.com

 
     
     
 
Home  |  About Us  |  Services  |  Buying & Owning Guide  |  Investing in CR  |  CaribeSur Info  |  Maps  |  Related Links  |  Contact Us
For Sale  |  For Rent  |  Submit Property

©2009 CARIBE SUR Real Estate, S.A.
Privacy Policy
Design & Hosting by manooLOGIK, inc